Make an Enquiry

27 Jan

2025

Is it Cheaper to Have a Live-in Carer or Care Home?

28 Jan

2025

Is it Cheaper to Have a Live-in Carer or Care Home?

When considering care options for yourself or a loved one, cost often plays a significant role in the decision-making process. While both live-in care and care homes have their place, understanding the full financial implications of each option helps make an informed choice that ensures the best care outcome.

Understanding the True Cost of Live-in Care

Live-in care might initially seem like a cost-effective option, but it's important to understand all the hidden costs beyond just the carer's salary. The United Kingdom Homecare Association outlines various factors that contribute to the total cost.

Direct Care Costs

The basic cost of live-in care typically ranges from £1,000 to £1,400 per week. However, this base rate often doesn't include:

  • Holiday cover for your carer
  • Employer's National Insurance contributions if directly employed
  • Agency fees and administration costs
  • Emergency backup care arrangements

Moreover, these costs can increase significantly when:

  • Complex care needs require specially trained carers
  • Multiple carers are needed for safe moving and handling
  • Night-time support is required
  • Specialist medical care is needed

Beyond just the carer's wages, you'll need to consider the broader financial picture. This includes providing suitable accommodation for your carer, increased household bills, and additional insurance requirements. Many people don't realise that having a live-in carer can impact their home insurance and may require specific employer's liability insurance.

Hidden Costs of Home Care

When opting for live-in care, numerous additional expenses often get overlooked. The MoneyHelper guide to care choices highlights several important considerations.

Household Expenses

Maintaining a home suitable for care delivery involves ongoing costs:

  • Higher utility bills from increased occupancy
  • Additional food and household supplies
  • Maintenance and repairs
  • Safety modifications and equipment

These expenses continue year-round, even during periods when your regular carer is on holiday or sick leave, during which you'll also be paying for replacement care.

The requirement to maintain the entire property to a suitable standard for care delivery can be particularly challenging. This might include ensuring adequate heating throughout the house, maintaining accessibility features, and keeping all facilities in good working order - costs that aren't necessary in a purpose-built care environment.

The Benefits of Care Home Environments

Care homes offer a more comprehensive and often more cost-effective solution than many people realise. Purpose-built environments provide economies of scale that can make high-quality care more affordable while offering additional benefits that aren't available with live-in care.

Inclusive Care Package

Most care homes provide an all-inclusive package covering:

  • 24/7 professional care availability
  • All meals and refreshments
  • Utilities and maintenance
  • Social activities and entertainment
  • Laundry and housekeeping

In a care home setting, these services are delivered more efficiently than they could be in an individual home environment, often resulting in better value for money when all costs are considered.

The Value Proposition of Care Homes

When comparing costs between live-in care and care homes, it's essential to consider the complete package of services and support provided. Care homes often deliver better value through their comprehensive approach to care and support.

Professional Care Team Advantages

Unlike live-in care, which relies heavily on one or two individuals, care homes provide access to an entire team of professionals. This includes:

  • Qualified nursing staff when needed
  • Experienced care assistants
  • Dedicated activity coordinators
  • Specialist dementia care experts

This team approach ensures consistent, high-quality care without the additional costs of arranging backup care or holiday cover. It also means expertise is always available, reducing the need for expensive emergency arrangements or specialist consultations.

The presence of multiple care professionals also provides better monitoring and early intervention for potential health issues, potentially reducing long-term care costs through preventative measures.

Social and Lifestyle Benefits

Care homes offer significant social and lifestyle advantages that would be expensive or impossible to replicate with live-in care. The Age UK guide to choosing care homes highlights how these benefits contribute to overall wellbeing.

Built-in Social Environment

A vibrant social environment includes:

  • Regular organised activities
  • Communal dining experiences
  • Shared spaces for socialisation
  • Visiting entertainment and events

These social aspects, which come as part of the care home package, would require significant additional expense to arrange in a home care setting.

Long-term Financial Stability

Care homes often provide more predictable long-term costs compared to live-in care. While the initial fees might seem substantial, they typically include:

Fixed Cost Advantages

Care home fees usually cover:

  • All care needs, including increasing care requirements
  • Building maintenance and repairs
  • Utility bills and council tax
  • Insurance and liability coverage
  • Food and housekeeping services

This comprehensive package often proves more cost-effective than managing multiple separate expenses with live-in care, particularly as care needs increase over time.

Making an Informed Decision

When evaluating care options, consider both immediate and long-term financial implications. The Which? guide to care choices recommends considering:

Total Cost Analysis

Look beyond basic fees to consider:

  • Potential increases in care needs
  • Property maintenance costs
  • Emergency care arrangements
  • Social and activity provisions

Quality of Life Considerations

While cost is important, the quality of life impact should be a key factor in decision-making. Care homes often provide:

Comprehensive Support Structure

Modern care homes offer:

  • Purpose-built facilities
  • Safety and security features
  • Emergency response systems
  • Specialist equipment when needed

These features come as standard in most care homes, whereas implementing them for live-in care would require significant additional investment.

Experience Quality Care at Ashberry Care Homes

At Ashberry Care Homes, we understand that choosing between care options involves careful consideration of both costs and quality of life. Our homes provide comprehensive, high-quality care that often proves more cost-effective than live-in care arrangements when all factors are considered.

We offer:

  • Transparent, all-inclusive fee structures
  • No hidden costs or unexpected charges
  • Regular care reviews to ensure needs are met
  • Professional team support around the clock
  • Home-from-home living environment

Contact our friendly team today to discuss your care needs and discover how our comprehensive care packages can provide both value for money and peace of mind. We'll help you understand all the costs involved and find a care solution that offers the best possible value while ensuring exceptional care quality.

Need a hand finding the right care home?

At Ashberry Care Homes, we look after your loved ones with care focused on dignity, sensitivity and independence.

We understand the concerns that people have when choosing a care home either for themselves or for a loved one. In our care, residents and their families are at the heart of everything we do and are always treated with respect and consideration.

Get in touch
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.